Happily Ever After: Avoiding a Nightmare Real Estate Claim
Kate Gould, Esq.
November 12, 2026
Reading time: 3 minutes

As a young child, you may have relished climbing into bed at the end of the day for a bedtime story to send you off to sleep. And while many fairy tales told of magical creatures in faraway lands and handsome princes rescuing fair maidens, revisiting other stories from your childhood now might surprise you given the dark themes and frightening characters. (How did we ever go to sleep?!) But could these classic fables you enjoyed as a child now serve as cautionary tales to protect against a malpractice claim?
You may recall a few fairy tales where a property’s inviting appearance concealed some troubling surprises. Little Red Riding Hood arrived at her grandmother’s house to find the Big Bad Wolf posing as its rightful occupant. And Hansel and Gretel discovered that a beautiful gingerbread house (in which they were later falsely imprisoned – if we are keeping track of legal theories to be learned before bed) came with hidden dangers – a reminder about when something looks too good to be true, it usually is. Â
As scammers grow increasingly more sophisticated, so do their deceptive practices. In other words, the story your client (or supposed client) tells you could be pure fiction. Recent real world claims involving residential real estate sales include transactions which appeared legitimate but ultimately resulted in a call to a legal malpractice carrier. For example, a mother and son sought to refinance a property to obtain a sizable loan. The firm that handled the closing paperwork for the son did not know the mother was also simultaneously (and fraudulently) obtaining the same financing on the same property. Because her loan was recorded before the son’s loan, the son’s mortgage company was in second position and completely unsecured. In another matter, a firm handled what appeared to be a vacant property purchase. However, once the transaction was finalized, the firm discovered the actual property owner had no intention of selling the property and had not even listed the property or agreed to sell it.
Claims like these leave lawyers wishing they could wake up and discover it was all a bad dream. The cautionary tale? A seemingly simple real estate transaction can lead you into unfamiliar woods when real estate law is not part of your regular practice. “It’s just a contract,” you might think, especially when a client wants a quick closing or an extra fee promises a welcome year-end boost. But that straightforward deal may be a wolf in disguise, concealing complexities your usual practice has not prepared you to recognize. Before accepting the work, consider whether you have the knowledge, experience, time, and safeguards to handle it competently. Rule 1.1 of the Model Rules requires competent representation, including the legal knowledge, skill, thoroughness, and preparation reasonably necessary for the engagement. An approaching closing date is no substitute for that preparation, and an apparently routine matter is no guarantee of a happy ending. If you lack the experience or time to develop the necessary competence and put appropriate safeguards in place, resist the pull of the fee and decline the representation.
The moral of this story? Don’t let an inviting fee lure you off the familiar path of your primary practice and into unfamiliar woods of residential real estate law. A seemingly simple transaction may conceal a thicket of complications – and without the relevant experience, you may not recognize the warnings signs until you are caught in the trap. Even experienced real estate lawyers can fall prey to fraudsters, making caution all the more important for those who rarely handle these matters. Before accepting the work, carefully assess whether you have the knowledge, preparation, safeguards, and time to handle it competently and ethically. If you cannot meet those demands, resist the temptation and decline the representation. A happy ending begins with knowing which paths not to take.Â

Join AttPro on November 18th for Socially Acceptable: The Ethics of Using Social Media
Additional Practice Areas content

A Side of Strategy: Thanksgiving Tips for Reducing Risk for Family Law Attorneys
Thanksgiving may bring thoughts of turkey, traditions, and favorite side dishes, but for many family law clients, it can also serve up parenting-time disputes, travel conflicts, financial strain, and simmering tensions during an ongoing divorce. Thankfully, a little planning can keep those issues from boiling over into urgent calls and emergency motions. By helping clients […]

Save The Date: Calculating and Calendaring EEOC Filing DeadlinesÂ
Calendaring various filing deadlines with the EEOC can feel a bit like juggling your social schedule, though it takes additional calculating. As you know, anti-discrimination laws allow for a limited amount of time to file a charge. Like any filing deadline, the clock may start running long before your client contacts you, shortening your time to investigate the circumstances and file the charge. For quick reference – like the Save The Date magnet prominently displayed on your refrigerator – keep this list handy for calculating and calendaring your filing deadlines:Â

(Micro)scope of Representation: Taking a Closer Look at Your Engagement Letter
When someone is injured on the job, it takes a skilled lawyer to help them navigate the worker’s compensation process. While this practice area feels foreign to many practitioners, you are uniquely qualified to handle what can be a complex and emotional process for your client. However, because your legal services may be solely limited to a worker’s comp claim, it is critical to explicitly state the scope of your representation in your engagement letter. In other words, a high resolution review of your form fee agreement is required before securing the client’s signature to ensure you narrowly tailor it to the intended representation.
Information provided by AttPro Ally is not intended as legal advice. This publication provides best practices for use in connection with general circumstances and ordinarily does not address specific situations. Specific situations should be discussed with legal counsel licensed in the appropriate jurisdiction. By publishing practice and risk prevention tips, Attorney Protective neither implies nor provides any guarantee that claims can be prevented by the use of the suggested practices. Though the contents of AttPro Ally have been carefully researched, Attorney Protective makes no warranty as to its accuracy, applicability, or timeliness. Anyone wishing to reproduce any part of the AttPro Ally content must request permission from Attorney Protective by calling 877-728-8776 or sending an email to [email protected].
© 2026 AttPro Ally. All rights reserved.