Board Games: Winning Strategies for Ethically Serving on Non-Profit Boards
October 3, 2024
Reading time: 3 minutes
As attorneys, we are frequently asked to join non-profit boards. Non-profit organizations are eager to add legal professionals with critical-thinking skills and community ties to their boards, believing they may also benefit from some “free” legal advice. Making time to serve on a board is a great way to give back and engage with your local community. While we should welcome these opportunities, we must be aware of the potential ethical Trouble an attorney could encounter. Be mindful of these factors before you accept a board appointment, or you might be Sorry!
- Your role – Before accepting a board position, it is crucial to define your role. Will you be serving as a board member only? Or, will you be a board member and the organization’s attorney? Clarifying your role before the lines are blurred is critical to protecting against potential conflicts and inadvertently creating an attorney-client relationship. If you are not the board’s attorney, be mindful of the guidance you offer and specifically state that you are not giving legal advice so it is documented in the meeting minutes.
- Potential conflicts – In our everyday legal practices, we must continually monitor the development of conflicts in our cases. When an attorney serves the dual role of board member and legal counsel, conflicts can also quickly arise. For example, an attorney should not participate in a vote to determine whether their law firm should be retained as outside counsel. Or, if the attorney offers legal advice, they cannot vote as a board member on the same matter. Be on guard for potential conflicts so as to not Risk an ethical violation.
- Independent judgment – A specific conflict of interest can arise concerning an attorney’s loss of independence when serving as a board member and the organization’s attorney. Board members have a duty of loyalty to the organization, and attorneys have a duty to exercise independent judgment. Under Model Rule 1.7, this concurrent conflict of interest can develop if the attorney’s independent professional judgment would be clouded when asked to give legal advice on a board decision they have other opinions on when wearing the board member hat.
So, what are best practices when serving on a non-profit board? The board and attorney should thoughtfully consider whether the board appointment best suits both parties. And, if you want to play fair and square, keep these tips in mind:
- Use an engagement letter – If you do accept the dual role of board member and attorney, clearly define these roles and state the scope of representation in an engagement letter. You should also obtain informed written consent from the board concerning the potential risks and conflicts of interest related to these roles.
- Recuse yourself when necessary – Always be wary of conflicts – or the appearance of a conflict – and err on the side of recusing yourself from a board vote if such circumstances exist.
- Review your coverage – Be sure to check whether your professional liability coverage or the board’s D&O insurance coverage extends to the legal advice you offer while serving on the board.
If you’re going to play the game, you have to play by the (ethical) rules. Keep these tips in mind before making your next move to join a non-profit board, and you can be winner!
Additional Ethics content
Ghosting Your Ex (Client)? Navigating Duties to Former Clients
No attorney can be fully insulated from a legal malpractice claim or grievance, but there are certain precautions that can be taken to minimize exposure to such claims. One important risk management tool is the strict screening of all cases before they are accepted into the practice. Rejecting cases with certain “red flags” can go a long way in preventing otherwise avoidable malpractice claims and grievances. Here are eight important questions to ask before accepting any new case.
Small Talk: Communication With A Represented Party
As the holiday party season approaches, crowded calendars and endless small talk become part of the seasonal ritual. After long days spent negotiating or advising clients, the idea of casual mingling may sounds harmless – until a friendly chat turns into something more complicated. In the relaxed glow of an after-work gathering, it is easier than ever to forget professional boundaries and accidentally strike up a conversation with someone represented by another lawyer. These inadvertent exchanges can carry serious ethical implications and remind us that professionalism doesn’t take the night off – even during the holiday season.
As a population who likely entered law school seeing the world in black and white, we had to quickly get comfortable operating in the gray. What is a legal gray area? It is a situation we often encounter in practice where existing law does not neatly apply but where an opportunity exists to allow counsel to present an argument which may ultimately lead to new developments in the law. Not only does this require creative advocacy, but also an adherence to our Rules of Professional Conduct. So, as you develop those arguments, consider your ethical obligations under Model Rule 3.1.
Information provided by AttPro Ally is not intended as legal advice. This publication provides best practices for use in connection with general circumstances and ordinarily does not address specific situations. Specific situations should be discussed with legal counsel licensed in the appropriate jurisdiction. By publishing practice and risk prevention tips, Attorney Protective neither implies nor provides any guarantee that claims can be prevented by the use of the suggested practices. Though the contents of AttPro Ally have been carefully researched, Attorney Protective makes no warranty as to its accuracy, applicability, or timeliness. Anyone wishing to reproduce any part of the AttPro Ally content must request permission from Attorney Protective by calling 877-728-8776 or sending an email to [email protected].
© 2026 AttPro Ally. All rights reserved.